Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Unrecognized Prosperity Gospel

A simple but well written article on some of the effects of the so-called Prosperity Gospel, by Anglican Bishop Michael Ingham, was recently published by TOPIC, the newspaper of the Diocese of New Westminster.

http://www.vancouver.anglican.ca/Portals/0/MARCH%202013/03_2013%20Topic_finalfinalforweb.pdf

Reading the article got me thinking about the subtle way that tentacles of this particular teaching have reached out and encompassed the thinking of all manner of Christians over the past 4 decades since this way of interpreting Scripture first became popular.  Christians who scoff at the prosperity gospel teachings that if you have sufficient faith then God will reward you with temporal riches up the yin yang are not immune to actually living their lives in ways that give credence to that interpretation of the Bible.

One of the subtleties many of us have unwittingly bought into, it seems to me, is the idea that while God may not have blessed me with the big house, huge bank account, fancy sports car etc. to let me know my faith has been sufficiently activated, I do seem to be blessed with an abundance of JOY and HAPPINESS as I go about my activities each week.  Apparently the ongoing happiness I am experiencing is just as much a sign of God's blessing on the way I live my life as the influx of temporal belongings is supposed to be, according to the more overt disciples of the Prosperity Gospel.

The assumption that an abundance of happiness is also a sign that my faith is moving me in the right direction can also create spiritual blindness.  Both abundance of riches and abundance of joy that lead us away from the idea that suffering is also part of the Christian life and experience can delude us about our walk with God and with his church.

Think about it:  in both cases it is easy for a certain amount of self-satisfaction to creep in.  All my temporal needs are taken care of with relative ease, my emotional needs are taken care of and I enjoy my life.  Not necessarily a problem, right?  But if we assume them to be a sign of God's blessing on our choices and then those things and those joys begin to hinder our involvement with God's people and his Church, perhaps we need to question what is really going on.


While it is obvious to many Christians that riches are not the automatic sign of God's blessing in all cases, sometimes we do not apply the same assumption to our apparent emotional riches such as joy and happiness.

Slowly we begin to assume that any activity we participate in must be God's will for us any time and any place simply because the result of participating in the activity makes us happy.  Any time we are happy it must be because we are pleasing God and receiving his blessing.  It isn't always a conscious thought that brings on conscious decision making about how we are spending our time.  We don't always arrive at that conclusion by thinking deeply about our activities and how they are effecting our lives in the Church or our brothers and sisters in our Christian community.

When I can't attend church events because I choose to take my children to hockey or I choose to go for brunch or to sleep in, or I choose any number of other priorities over committment to God's people and Church on a regular basis and assume it is always okay because I always have such fun doing those things during church event times, am I falling into the trap of assuming the degree of my emotional feelings of happiness are indicating the degree of God's blessing?

After all, if I go to church or spend lots of my social time with my Christian community I am likely going to have to spend time at least occasionally with people who are not nice to me, or who irritate me or who don't understand me. The preacher may say things that make me aware of my own need for change in my life and that will take work on my part.  I may be asked to help with events I have little personal interest in.  I may have to take my children to Sunday School to learn more about Jesus at a time when they need to be exploring their potential in more temporal arenas of life and what kind of parent would I be if I didn't allow them to do whatever activity they want to do even when it interferes with an important thing like learning why they need to follow Jesus?  

In other words, being involved with God's people and Church may require sacrificing some things that make me happy and which cause me and my family to suffer inconvenience or irritability or the loss of some other deeply enjoyable activity.  And God doesn't want us to suffer, right?  He wants to bless us with peace and happiness and fun and games, right?  Jesus died on the cross so I would never have to suffer, right?  It is more important that my kids spend their growing up years discovering they are not actually going to be the next Miss Teen Canada or Wayne Gretzky, right?  

Ever so slowly we change our habits from spending time sacrificing for the Kingdom of God to sacrificing for other activities which draw us ever farther away from Kingdom values and Kingdom life, because it is so much easier in the short term, so much more fun.  

Like the more overt followers of the Prosperity Gospel we become distracted by what makes us immediately happy instead of realizing our focus as God's people is to be on his community, his church, the work of his kingdom.  We assume that what makes us happy is a sign from God that we are in the right places at the right times.

The idea of making personal sacrifices for our churches and for our brothers and sisters in Christ is slowly dying.  Church attendance and committment to Christ's body here on earth have become the optional events for Christians in North America.  Our children and grandchildren no longer attend church or become involved in Christian community and we wonder why that is.  Yet we are the ones who opted out of church and community by catering to so many other activities in our attempt to expose them to all manner of things that are not bad in themselves, but that we set up as being far more important than what our Christian communities are offering.  They have no interest in Jesus or Church because we their parents and grandparents taught them that being disciples of Jesus is not a priority.  We are the ones who taught them that church is optional and that temporal activities are more important.  We have endangered our own families in their faith and their spiritual committments because we fell for the lie that says for Christians happiness and temporal things trump the possibilities of suffering through discipleship.  

Corporate Christian worship and the joy that goes along with is has been replaced by Sunday morning coffee at "Tim's" or "Mickey D's".  These things make us happy, they require no sacrifice and the worst suffering they can offer us is the occasional mug of tepid coffee.  And if we are happy then God must be blessing us, right?

It is so subtle and we are falling for it.  

I don't know how to fix this.  I do know how to pray and so that is what I can do.  I do know how to challenge myself and my own friends about how we spend our time and so that is what I can do.  But it is God who will have to turn this mentality around....and he will....and we probably won't enjoy it very much at some point along the way....but it will save us from the lies and bring us truly closer to him, to his church and community and to true joy.

5 comments:

Unknown said...

Wow! Good thoughts - ones that have been running around in my head for the last while. You have put them into a great read!!

Susan said...

Thank you for your comment Pastor Ron! As a non-academic, non-theologian I am always hesitant to write about such things, particularly in a blog format where so much of the research or thought process has to be left out for the sake of length. I appreciate this encouragement to keep thinking and reading and researching.

Bill Erlenbach said...

Good words Sue.

Perhaps instead of calling it the prosperity gospel we should simply call it the happy gospel or even the blessing gospel. Funny thing is that the way of blessing we seek rarely has much to do with the way of blessing Jesus taught.

Susan said...

I have a friend that calls it the Happy Clappy Gospel. I am sure it has been around much longer than the past 40 years that I have been hearing about it, but it certainly has effected us all in one way or another. I would so LOVE to be able to believe it, tried it on for size for a couple of years and it was disastrous, but Jesus was, as you say, rarely talking about temporal prosperity.

Susan said...

Oops, sorry: my friend is a WHO not a THAT!