Sunday, May 12, 2013

Punishment Inflicted vs Personal Choice

The concept of "hell" seems to have re-entered the wonderful world of philosophical and theological conversation these days.  With the documentary style film "Hellbound" about to hit the theatres, the topic will be, at least briefly, newspaper, entertainment and religious tv show, blogger and twitter newsworthy.  Once again many of us will feel we must inject our own opinions, well researched and otherwise, into the social media arena.

So, I am going to take the plunge myself today, since I have some time to fill and not a lot to think about at the moment, having just spent 2 hours hobbling about washing floors and bathroom fixtures and feeling somewhat too sore to do much else until tomorrow's cleanathon part two.

I don't feel very well educated in the concept of hell, so I won't say a lot.  What I don't understand I suppose, is why Christians in particular seem bent on re-interpreting God to be a loving being based on our own human/personal interpretations of "love" and what it entails.  We seem to want love to be always something warm and fuzzy and soft and happy and gentle.  The idea that in order to love perfectly there is sometimes pain of some kind involved for the ultimate future redemption of created beings such as ourselves, has become repugnant, repulsive and too unenlightened for us to believe any more.  A loving God would never send any of his creatures to a terrible sounding place like hell.  He would never use the fear of an eternity in hell to scare us into behaving properly and so as Christians neither must we.

Well, for myself, I happen to agree that God sends no one to hell. I do believe in hell. I do not believe that hell, whatever and wherever it may be, is a form of punishment for rejecting our Creator. I believe that an eternity in either a heaven with God or a hell without him is very much a choice that we participate in based on our own choices of whether or not we accept or deliberately reject our Creator. 

According to the Bible, one thing that seems clear and needs little further interpretation, is that even though we are created by God, we are not forced to believe in his existence, in his involvement in the universe or in our lives.  We are allowed to reject him.  Throughout the Bible stories I see nothing to indicate that God does not honour our choices.  While I believe he does everything he can to reveal his existence to us, if we choose to believe and live otherwise that is our choice to make.

If that is true, then why would God inflict himself for all eternity on people who spend their lives rejecting him?  If I choose to reject him in this life, why would he dishonour my choice and force himself into my afterlife when I die?  How disrespectful would God be of my choices if he did that? Would a loving God who allows me to choose my spiritual destiny then overrule my choice as to where I want to spend eternity:  with him or without him?

I can't pretend to know what an eternity in a place  known as hell would consist of.  There are many ways to interpret the scant details we are given in the Bible.  I choose to not attempt to do that. I am too busy trying to follow him in the here and now and figuring out what all that entails, because I am a slow learner.  All I can figure out for certain is that if I choose God in this life it should mean that I will get to spend my afterlife with him as well.  If I don't I won't.

This is a simple blog, not a research paper, but those are just a few of my thoughts...more questions than answers of course, but I do believe in a loving and all powerful God as is represented in the stories of the Christian Bible, a Father who allows his children to choose for themselves whether or not they want to accept him in this world and therefore the next; a Father who honours the choices of his Creation even when those choices are breaking his heart. 

No comments: