Tuesday, May 12, 2020

Don't Bother, OK?

Rider:  I DO know I am too sensitive about this issue.

However:  As much as I understand church and other leaders wanting to care for their congregations and community group members by ensuring everyone has a chance to stay connected during this time of isolation, I am always bitterly disappointed when I discover, after a lovely chat with someone from my church or other community group, the person on the other end of the phone line has called me BECAUSE my name has been assigned to them by someone else as a "obligatory check in", for lack of a better way to phrase it. When that happens, no matter how lovely the conversation, I feel conned.  Sorry, I know that is overstating it and that it is not the most gracious reaction, but I do.

Explanation: I was in a pseudo Christian cult group long ago and spent my fair share of time having people "assigned" to me by the leaders of the group. My job (called a ministry, unfortunately) was to ensure the people on my list were made to feel cared about, were made to feel safe enough to open up and allow themselves to be drawn into the clutches of the group.  People became nothing more than projects and when the project was eventually completed...ie the person became a member of the group....that specific "project" was over and I was assigned someone else to fraudulently befriend.  Some cults called that kind of activity "fishing".  Mine didn't use such blatant terminology, but the actions and outcomes were similar.


So: when I get a call from someone to who I have been assigned for contact, I feel terrible.  Although the person calling me now is not trying to rope me into anything because I am all ready a part of the church or community group she or he represents, it is upsetting to me that I have been led to believe this person, often someone who I don't really know all that well, actually thought about me unprompted and cared enough about my welfare to enquire after it.  To  be frank, it hurts my feelings. I have been fortunate in that the last 2 assigned callers told me somewhere between the middle and end of the conversation that my name had been assigned to them, so it wasn't a shock later on, but it still hurt to some degree knowing that if there was no isolation happening and no assigned phone list, they would not feel enough interest to be in touch with me.

Too sensitive?  Too ungrateful?   Yes, likely.  

However, perhaps if you are a person who is busy with an assigned list of contacts through this time of pandemic, you should search your own heart before calling each person and ask yourself if you would really have any interest in that person apart from participating in an assigned calling list. If the answer is "no", don't bother picking up that phone, okay? Creating an interest in what is actually a false attempt at friendship is not going to help anyone. Sometimes it can create more hurt than intended.

Do you have an assigned phone list or are you a person responsible for creating them?

Just think about it before you act, okay?

2 comments:

chris e. said...

Thank you, thank you, thank you, for this post! Thank you for being so candid and truthful!

Susan said...

There are those assigned callers who do so happily and out of a heart of true concern, but that generally is obvious and easier to take. I don’t think assigned lists are always bad, just that more careful thought should go into them than sometimes does.