Saturday, November 28, 2020

It's NOT Always Either/Or!

 Reductionist thinking when it comes to politics and philosophy in this day and age is really getting to me.  Very few issues are of the clear cut "either/or" variety.

The USA is really struggling with this mentality right now and I see more of it creeping across our own borders as well.  We are unnecessarily dividing into two opposing camps.  People we don't even know well are being labeled as:

Conservative or Liberal

Republican or Democrat

Always right or always wrong depending on which of the previous two categories we have mindlessly boxed other people into.

Demon/Saviour

Good/Evil

 Patriotic/Traitorous

 

If we can demonize those who disagree with us then it is easier to support the other person we have put into the category of savior.  There doesn't have to be much logical thought or research put into this kind of mentality.  It is herd mentality and when it reaches into the uppermost echelons of "civilized" society it is dangerous at best.

 An election issue that has upset me greatly in recent elections on both sides of the border is the issue of:
 

Pro-life/Abortion

 When I meet fellow Christians who vote for politicians based solely on their views of this issue, pro or con, little if any research into their other stances on taxes or health care or what have you, it grates on my last nerve.  No election is a one issue campaign.  There has to be discussion, thought, research into a country's policies as a whole.  If we are going to be knowledgeable voters we have to understand and accept that none of the political parties are 100% right or wrong on this or any  other issue  We are losing the ability to even want to think our way through the larger landscape of political and philosophical issues in play when we live in a democracy, to participate in discussion with those people we think we will not agree with.  It seems as though many Christian brothers and sisters are using agreement or disagreement with one issue (and not always the abortion vs pro-life issue) as an excuse to do no further research, have no further discussion with those running for political office and whoever is in the party with opposing views on their pet issue is some kind of satanic force.  We are, speaking very generally of course, becoming a politically lazy, uninformed bunch too much of the time.  We are developing a confusing mix of religion, philosophy, nationalism and politics, to our long term detriment.

 After a discussion this morning with some people who will radically disagree with this post, I became frustrated enough to air this view of my own.  Forgive me if it bothers you and I am not remotely suggesting that my own level of research into issues is adequate for the most informed possible vote or discussion either, but I know I have to keep trying my best to get beyond a one issue election vote, I have to refuse to demonize people who own a different world view than I do, particularly in certain areas of morality, and I cannot allow myself to look at all politicians, philosophers, Christian leaders etc. and make a judgement call that writes them off simply because we disagree on one or two issues.  It takes a lot of time and effort to do the research necessary and to try  to participate in discussions where disagreements happen, but I know I have to keep trying.  No one out there is completely good or bad, black or white in their thinking, completely liberal or completely conservative.  We are all human beings with many influences that have formed our world view and we need to start trying to understand each other instead of instantly writing each other off over one issue where we disagree.

There, end of rant.  Thank you for your patience.  

No comments: