My son's partner is a playwright and producer, so she attends all manner of plays around the city to learn all she can about her craft. Last night she took me to a see a new play at the Broadhurst Theatre: "The Hills of California" by Jez Butterworth and directed by Sam Mendes. It received rave reviews in the New York Times but as is often the case I am afraid I had to disagree at least somewhat with the reviewer. The play was very very well produced and directed and had a stellar British cast of which the lead actor, Laura Donnelly, was a standout. She was so easy to watch, so at ease with both characters that she plays. I enjoyed her, as well as the rest of the cast. Unfortunately the play didn't live up to the hype of being "relentlessly entertaining". It was just a bit too old fashioned in style for me, although due to the time period in which the play is set I, as well as the rest of the mostly grey haired audience, understood and appreciated many of the cultural references of the day. (Large scale Broadway productions are losing popularity among the younger generations who live their lives with sound bytes and short series' of images passing by, so theatre requires too much linear thinking and concentration it seems for many of them. Also the ticket prices are beyond some of them.)
The characters were more caricatures and the four sisters being portrayed didn't seem to be believably related to each other as siblings much of the time. There were many old tropes, some of the script seemed contrived to me and there was no surprise or twist to the story....an event revealed in the final scenes that was apparently supposed to be a secret to many of the characters was obvious to the audience from the last scene prior to intermission, so I felt let down. Of the various issues and problems faced by the characters it seemed none of them were ever resolved....difficult to swallow in such a linear movement script.
Despite my bit of disappointment that the play wasn't what I was expecting of hoping for on some levels, there were some very enjoyable things too. There were some witty lines, the production itself was very well done, the directing was excellent with the kind of blocking that included a reason for every movement across the stage that each actor made and Laura Donnelly was absolutely worth watching.
I enjoyed my first trip to a large Broadway theatre. It was so much fun just being in the audience, milling about at intermission, fighting through the crowds to get back to the subway after the performance, as there were several theatres in the area letting out at the same time. It wasn't Tokyo Crowded, so it was easy enough to get around.
The experience was quite a contrast to the Not Broadway play we all attended the other night. This play, "Buildings l and ll" by Richard Maxwell, was produced on the now deserted 19th floor of an older empty building in the now dying, once vibrant Financial District, where too many such monuments to 19th century architecture are selling off for 8%-10% of their real estate value. The Financial District is one area of the city decimated by COVID (and several other longer term problems) as financiers realized they could work from home longer than the pandemic demanded and more buildings became abandoned to save having to pay the constant upkeep such places demand.
This particular building was purchased by an artist here in the city who wanted to own a gallery space for his own works to be displayed....one Christopher Wool....and so the theatre area was right beside one of his latest exhibitions...which I won't comment on. The audience was sitting on a set of somewhat rickety looking bleachers, hammered together just for this performance and to be honest I am intensely grateful that due to my perceived to be highly disabled state, the ticket sellers reserved seats for our party on the floor in front of the bleachers....hard metal chairs of the same type we sat in at school assemblies back in the 1960's....and there were cushions of somewhat suspect quality on each of the four seats. There we sat on the original concrete floors from which the fancy old tiles had been pulled up and were long gone and the bare white, somewhat marked up walls, surrounded by the large windows that let in just the right light conditions throughout the progression of the play, so as to be part of the set. It was really, really a fun venue and the crowd was much younger. What a wonderful contrast to be in this stripped down space as part of an audience of about 125, as well as the much more opulent Broadway Theatre surrounded by a crowd of at least 600 others.
This play, while reported to apparently not be one of the playwright's best was a wonderful more experimental style of theatre. The acting was stripped down, the set was absolutely bare minimum, as were the costume styles, but I found myself much more engaged with the characters than I was at the Broadway play. I felt closer emotionally to their struggles and just generally more connected to what each character was going through. There was a partially linear story line, but there were interesting events and musical additions that on one hand didn't seem to connect to anything at all about the original story line and yet pulled the entire production together in an interesting way. There was a better resolve for many of the issues experienced by the characters, a few surprises to keep up our interest.
I enjoyed both plays for different reasons, but had the best internal connection to the Maxwell play.
I love live theatre that is well done and wow, this is the city to find such things!
2 comments:
So I now learn that, as well as being an amazing restaurant 'critic', you do a bang-up job as a theatre reviewer. You made it so interesting the way you contrasted the two play experiences. You are having such fun!!
Well, I have opinions that may or may not be valid so my own blog is the best place to express them….it is fun for me. I truly miss living on a city with these types of professional productions, although the arts community tries very hard here and has lots of success.
Post a Comment