Wednesday, July 25, 2012

Opinion Polls

Does anyone else out there find online opinion polls as annoying as I do?  

Case in point:  one newspaper poll this morning asked if a particular provincial premier would be able to sell Canadian politicians on a national energy policy.  As is so often the case the choices to vote for were either YES or NO. 

What would be the point of voting in this poll?  How on earth would I or anyone else know for certain if one premier's NEP could be bought into by the rest of my country's elect?


There was little other information outlining the details of this NEP in any of the surrounding newpaper articles. Even if the politicians involved were close personal friends, I would have nothing with which to form an opinion as to the probablility of them accepting an NEP presented by one of their fellow pols. 

As is becoming the norm it seems, articles on this subject were so lacking in details as to what this NEP would entail that I personally would have zero idea of its national viability.  Such articles, in fact articles on most any subject these days, are written as if the readers have all ready accessed a previous information source that will tell them what is being written about. Newspaper articles and public online opinion polls seem to be put together for only an elite "in-crowd" who all ready know from other sources what these articles and polls are actually about.


Newspaper and website opinion polls are designed to make us out to be ignorant sots who want to answer questions on issues that we know nothing about or have no earthly importance whatsoever.  They are designed to make us think our opinions are worth something, even when we really have no basis to form an opinion.  They are offensive at worst and a waste of time at best. I suspect the writers of the polls know these things and are laughing heartily at our collective expense.

So may I offer just a few more voting options for these online polls?  I think they are valid options and would represent a far more truthful and realistic overview of Canadian opinions on almost any subject.  Here they are for your perusal:

1.  How would I know?

2.  Why would I want to know?

3.  Why would YOU want to know?

4.  Why in blazes would ANYONE want to know?


5.  How is this any of my business?

6.  How is this any of your business?



7.  Are you kidding me??


AND my all time favourite and most pertinent voting option:

8.  WHO CARES?????


2 comments:

chris e. said...

I think the current 'give your opinion even though you have no knowledge' phenomena is a natural outgrowth of the whole self-esteem movement. For the last 30 years people have been raised hearing they're worthy/competent/flawless etc, instead of learning from experience that they're fallible and don't know everything right off the bat. So no doubt they think their opinion is just as valuable as someone who actually knows what they're talking about.
As for me, i like your 8 points! Maybe you could develop them into a 12 step programme for ignoramuses.

Susan said...

This is exactly what I have noticed when people leave comments on newspaper websites. The arguing between the people commenting seems to intensify according to what is not actually known about the subject of the article being commented on.