I suspect we readers of biblical scriptures have been guilty in some instances of giving a particular Pharisee in one of Jesus' parables a bad rap and created a couple of caricatures from him and his prayer partner in Luke Chapter 18, verses 10 through 14: the spiritual villain vs the spiritual hero. Sometimes I think we miss the whole point of the parable in all its "radicalness".
"Two men went up into the temple to pray, one a Pharisee, and the other a tax-gatherer. The Pharisee stood and was praying thus to himself, 'God, I thank Thee that I am not like the other people, swindlers, unjust, adulterers, or even like this tax gatherer. I fast twice a week; I pay tithes on all that I get.'
But the tax-gatherer, standing some distance away, was even unwilling to lift up his eyes to heaven, but was beating his breast, saying, 'God, be merciful to me, the sinner!'
I tell you, this man went down to his house justified rather than the other; for one who exalts himself shall be humbled, but he who humbles himself shall be exalted." (NAS version)
Often we paint these two men with the wrong colours it seems. We vilify the righteously living Pharisee and turn the offensively living tax gatherer into a hero. Let's think about that though.
The Pharisee was not bragging about his ability to follow the Mosaic law as much as he was simply following common rabbinical practise of beginning his prayer with a recitation of all the laws he was obeying. That wasn't unusual. His declaration of relief that he was not like the other less devout people around him was not such a bad thing in terms of it continuing to point out the correctness of his way of life and of his devotion to God.
On the other hand it isn't right to overly spiritualize the tax-gatherer. He lived a life entirely offensive to his Jewish brethren. He collected taxes in whatever way was necessary from his own people and turned that money over to the very government that was oppressing them. He did not live a righteous life like the Pharisee did. The man was no hero.
To me, what is radical about the parable is that Jesus so quickly makes the point, in so few sentences, that God is willing and able to justify whoever he chooses; whoever recognizes that they are in need of God's mercy and forgiveness, whether or not they are living according to the spiritual practises and laws the rest of the community of God's people obey.
The Pharisee was not wrong in talking to God about how he had been able to keep the Mosaic Law; the difference between his prayer and that of the tax gatherer is that the Pharisee missed the point that even though he was living righteously it was still only God's grace and mercy that justified him. The tax gatherer was very aware of that. In this parable he doesn't attempt to justify his own vile behaviour but throws himself on the mercy of God.
I think that where we Christians too often get confused is when we assume it is our own efforts to obey God, our own efforts to run churches, our own efforts to pray whatever we deem to be "correct" sorts of prayers or worship in "correct" ways as defined by ourselves or our own particular church denominations, the way we feed the hungry or heal the wounds of the hurting people around us. When we start proudly telling the Lord, "Hey God, look what we did!" and forget that we only did it because of his gracious leading and supplying of ability and strength, that is when we start to lose sight of what our whole Christian walk is all about. Our Christian walk is not "us (the people who were 'smart' enough to choose to follow Jesus)" vs "them (the people who don't meet our particular spiritual or social standards of behaviour)" At that point we are like the Pharisee in that God may choose to humble us. (note that the Pharisee was setting himself up to be humbled by God, not damned)
Lots of Christians are behaving like the Pharisee in the parable. They truly are living righteous lives and more of us tax gatherer types could learn good things from them. However the Christian Pharisaical types sometimes forget that before God we are all equally guilty of spiritual imperfection no matter how righteously we live our earthly lives. We still need God's own justification.
The tax-gatherer types of Christians can also learn something, and that is when we are justified by the grace of God his grace is also available to help us transform the rest of our lives and behaviour.
To me, in this parable, there are no heroes nor villains, just those who recognize their intense need of God's grace to be justified and those who have simply forgotten from whence their ability to live righteously comes.
1 comment:
You are so right! I think the key phrase is that 'The Pharisee...was praying thus TO himself...' At some point he had passed awareness that although he was obeying laws his salvation was still completely on God's grace and had slipped into believing that his salvation was of his own making. What a lesson for the rest of us!
Post a Comment